Showing posts with label house rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label house rules. Show all posts

Monday, January 31, 2011

The Rules aren't a Black Box

There's a pet peeve of mine that I see come up a lot in RPG discussions - the idea that you can't houserule something until you've tried it rules-as-written. This is my reply to such a post on RPG.net.

Hm.

I think I've done pretty well, honestly, and I find it a little offensive to be painted as a sort of ignorant fool that doesn't 'really' understand the games I run.

It's really not that hard. Rules comprehension is a skill you can develop. The rules are not a black box, only revealing their effects through careful study during play. They're all laid out in the text in front of you. Some games (again, Exalted comes to mind) have everything so interlinked that it IS really a pain to work out the ramifications of even a minor change, but such is not always the case. Many games are fairly straightforward or modular in design, such that you can modify one part or another without doing any harm. Yes, there's a chance a house rule will be a mistake. But you don't need hours of playtesting and empirical evidence to realize that someone made a math error or didn't consider an important edge case when they wrote a rule. To use an extreme example, I really, really don't need to experience 'bucket healing' in play to decide that it's stupid and declare that drowning does not work that way.

In fact, sometimes empirical experience is actively a bad way to develop a houserule, especially when you're working with probabilities, as you often are in an RPG. Personal experience is notoriously susceptible to bias and superstition when dice are involved, while it's relatively easy to apply statistics and thought experiments to map out the results of a change.

A lot of game systems just have bad math, incomplete-but-interesting subsystems that could use a little more detail, and, often, contradictions that outright need house ruling because the RAW are incomprehensible.

'Bucket healing', by the way, came up earlier in the thread; it's a weird obvious loophole in the d20 drowning rules that lets you heal a dying (between -1 and -10 hp) character up to zero hit points by briefly drowning him, such as by dunking his head in a bucket of water for a short time.

Monday, August 16, 2010

If it ain't broke...

'If it ain't broke, don't fix it.'
A useful aphorism in many situations, but such a pain when playing around with game design.

You can pick even the most incomplete or obviously broken rule in an entire game, and if you post a suggested modification on a forum a great many people will still angrily defend it.

Granted, some house rules are just bad, but even those often fail to get a real discussion, with the actual forum threads buried under the combined cries of heresy (after all, a house-rules poster isn't a paid game designer and is thus inferior), elitist rules conservatism ('the rule as it is worked great for me, and I've been playing for 72 years!'), GM fiat ('you don't need rules for that, the GM should just make stuff up'), or even a sort of vague confusion on what house rules are ('but if you change that, things won't be the same!').

Oddly, it's worse the more broken the rule is. I posted a suggestion on making the Link +10% enhancement in GURPS cheaper, on the SJ Games forum and got a few people mildly upset but no real discussion on the rule. On the other hand, the threads on modifying some of the most obviously broken rules I've seen in gaming result in massive flame wars and arguments (Scion is the one that comes to mind most easily, with its haphazard nightmare of bad rules built into an otherwise great game.)

The best I can tell, this happens because if you say something is really broken, everyone that's used the broken rules (slogged through it, carefully avoided breaking it, or even just happily went along with the weirder results) feels threatened if you point out how broken it is, because you're in some sense telling them their game was 'wrong'.

I suppose that's a problem with any form of constructive criticism.

Monday, June 7, 2010

Bound in Word and Wonder

In mythology, fairy tales, and fantasy stories, the idea of a magically binding contract occasionally shows up, generally when dealing with powerful supernatural beings. An old witch sets a strange and impossible task for a child, but must let him go free when he somehow accomplishes it. A man bargains with the devil, trading away his hope for an afterlife in exchange for wealth and power in this life. A wizened little gnome promises to return the stolen child only if the mother can guess the gnome's name. However it works, there is something magical about these kinds of arbitrary mystically enforced rules. They reinforce the meaningfulness of even trivial interactions, and they give an air of storybook wonder to what could otherwise be dull tasks.

The idea of binding oaths and bargains is explored in many games. As far as I know, White Wolf's Changeling: The Lost is the first to really codify these agreements into an actual detailed system, though I'm sure others have come before. As such, the system I'm proposing here owes a lot to that game. My system is generic: the specific details will need to be filled in to fit whatever system it will be used with -- in my case, most like Ars Magica, Exalted, Changeling, and GURPS.

The Components of an Oath
Each oath is constructed from several components. Each component has a rating describing how significant it is, with a number associated with each rating:
  • Trivial (0)
  • Minor (1)
  • Moderate (2)
  • Major (3)
  • Mythic (5)
Each component is also described as 'positive', 'negative', or 'neutral.' Positive components add to the value of the oath, negative components subtract from it, and neutral components don't actually affect the oath's value at all. Oaths should generally sum to a total value of zero, excepting special rules to the contrary (some games might allow fairy lords to have positive-value oaths, or require oaths with demons to have a net negative value at some level, etc.)

Personal, Dual, and Group Oaths
A personal oath is the simplest to build; you just set the components together, make sure they add up to zero, and you're done. Many systems and settings either won't support personal oaths or will penalize them somehow, though, since they're lacking the aspect of interaction that is most of the purpose of magical oaths.
A dual oath is probably the standard; an agreement between two individuals. To build it, you design each individual's side of the oath as a separate oath and make sure the durations match and there are no contradictions. When one character breaks the oath, the other one involved has his end of the oath nullified as well but does not suffer any punishment for breaking an oath (since he didn't break it.)
A group oath works like a dual oath, except that when someone breaks their end of the oath, provided there are still at least two people sworn to it and the oath still makes sense, the oath is not nullified for the remaining characters. For instance, if a group of characters swear an alliance to each other and one turns traitor, the traitor suffers the punishment and loses the benefits of the oath, but the rest of the group is still bound to the alliance to one another.

Duration
Every oath requires a single Duration component, defining how long it lasts. Duration has a variable value; sometimes it is considered positive, other times negative, and sometimes neutral. This depends on the other components of the oath. If even one component states that it treats Duration as positive, it is a positive component. If no components treat duration as positive and at least one describes it as negative, it is negative. Otherwise, it is neutral.
  • Trivial Durations last no longer than a quarter of a day. Examples include: 'until sunset' (on an oath sworn at noon), 'an hour', 'the length of a sunrise' (about two minutes; the time it takes the sun to go from showing only a sliver to fully crossing the horizon), etc.
  • Minor Durations last up to a week. Examples include: 'until Sunday', 'when the sun has twice risen and fallen'.
  • Moderate Durations last for a long while, but significantly less than a year: 'for an entire lunar cycle', 'until the next solstice', 'forty days and forty nights', etc.
  • Major Durations last for long but finite spans of time. Examples include: 'until your child is born', 'for a year and a day', or even 'in a decade's time'.
  • Mythic Durations can be truly impressive: 'until the day you die', 'unto the seventh generation', 'for three centuries', etc. At this level there's no real limit to the duration, and oaths can even be set to last forever (provided nobody breaks the oath, of course.)
(part II, detailing 'Challenges', to come later)